I found out yesterday that there will soon be a College Baseball Hall of Fame. You can read about it at the website of the
College Baseball Foundation. It will be located in Lubbock, Texas. I have several thoughts on this, so I thought I'd share:
1. In one sense, I'm surprised there isn't already such a hall of fame for College Baseball in the US. But seemingly there isn't: see this list of
halls of fame from Wikipedia. Ones I certainly wasn't aware of include the halls for Gospel Music, international swimming, distance running, mountain biking, Canadian medicine, robots, and three -- yes three -- for professional wrestling. Given how popular it is in the US, I'm a bit surprised that College Basketball is not listed... unless I missed it. Is there a Hall of Fame for the NCAA Basketball? Or is its coverage in the general Basketball Hall of Fame the reason there isn't a separate one?
2. Then again, college baseball just isn't very popular in the US. It has a following to be sure, but it is very small compared to other college sports. And there is good reason for this. For some sports, the college level is arguably the highest level of achievement in that sport (in the US), because there isn't much of a professional league or whatnot. Then for men's Basketball and Football, the NBA and NFL rely on the college athletes as the training ground for their new players. Almost all players who are in the professional drafts come from the college teams (a bit less so lately for the NBA, given the rise of European basketball).
But baseball has a well-developed and longstanding minor-league system. Most players who are rookies on the major league teams come from the minor league teams. Yes, a few come straight from college, and more go from college to some level of the minors and then eventually the majors. But many others go from High School straight to the minors, bypassing college. This has to be the number one reason that American baseball fans largely don't follow the college game.
3. Given this, I think that CBF Chairman/CEO John Askins is overstating things a bit when he says:
"Just like Canton and Cooperstown, sports fans around the nation will begin to turn their attention to Lubbock every summer... This first-ever class of inductees will give our event a unique place in the history of sports. The national television exposure on the Fox networks will also showcase to the nation just how vibrant and growing an area the South Plains really is."
We'll see. That might be a bit optimistic. After the first year, and maybe one or two more, I predict most Americans, including most baseball fans, won't pay much attention.
4. The CBF link above also includes this paragraph:
The list of legendary former players include Dave Magadan of Alabama, Bob Horner of Arizona State, Mickey Sullivan of Baylor, Jackie Jensen of California, Tim Wallach of Cal State Fullerton, Derek Tatsuno of Hawai’i, Pete Incaviglia and Robin Ventura of Oklahoma State, Billy Swift of Maine, Neal Heaton of Miami, Barry Larkin of Michigan, Paul Molitor and Dave Winfield of Minnesota, Will Clark of Mississippi State, B. J. Surhoff of North Carolina, Steve Arlin of Ohio State, Brooks Kieschnick and Keith Moreland of Texas, Fred Lynn of USC, John Olerud of Washington State and Joe Carter and Phil Stephenson of Wichita State.
Of course I realize the context for this is their performance in College Baseball. Still, I have trouble seeing the word "legendary" applied to some of these players. Many of these guys were great players in the pros, a few are even enshrined at Cooperstown already. But then there are the other "legends" here like Magadan, Sullivan, Heaton, Arlin, Kieschnick, and Stephenson. I know, the context. I just never thought I'd see the word "legendary" applied to Neal Heaton. (Part of me is glad to see Pete Incaviglia's name in print again... though I don't know why exactly.)
The list of pre-1947 candidates, on the other hand, does include at least one true "legend" of our American culture: Lou Gehrig. Christy Mathewson was one of the top 10 pro pitchers of all-time, so he too is a "legend" of sorts. And at least Frankie Frisch (another Cooperstown HOFer) had a nickname named after his college, "The Fordham Flash."
5. I won't give you my votes for who should go in during this first year, mostly because I don't know enough about their college years -- and I assume that should be the main factor on who is most deserving of the honor. I'll be interested to see who gets in... for this first year at least.
Labels: baseball