In his Sunday column, local sportswriter Bob Mathews
presented his 2007 All-Star squad.
I agree with Prince Fielder at 1B, with Howard and Pena as honorable mention, although I might have also mentioned Albert Pujols. Although Prince Albert didn't have a typically awesome season, he did hit .327 with a .429 OBP, 32 HR, and 103 RBI.
I can along with Chase Utley at 2B, even though missed some games due to injury. He also mentions Cano and Polanco, while I might have mentioned Brian Roberts or Brandon Phillips in addition or instead. Especially Phillips, as he joined the 30/30 club with 30 HR and 32 SB.
I agree that it was a great year for NL shortstops, and I agree that Rollins was the best of them. Hanley Ramirez is a solid honorable mention, though I don't see how he can mention Jeter without also listing Reyes with his 78 SB and 119 Runs.
At 3B choosing A-Rod is a no-brainer, and I like the four he mentioned as also-rans: Chipper, Cabrera, Wright, and Lowell. And that still leaves out fine seasons from Atkins and Aramis Ramirez.
His catcher is Posada, which is a fine choice, since he gave V. Martinez and Russell Martin their due as honorable mentions.
David Ortiz had yet another great year hitting, so he is the clear choice at DH. Bob mentions Frank Thomas, who had a fine year as well.
In the OF, the three starters are Holliday, Ordonez, and Vlad Guerrero. I can't argue with those selections, and he also honors Ichiro, Carlos Lee, Granderson and Crawford. There are many others he could have mentioned as well, like at least Eric Byrnes given his important role for the playoff Diamondbacks.
Bob lists Jake Peavy as the top RHP, and that seems obvious. The top LHP title goes to C.C. Sabathia. For RHPs he mentions Penny, Carmona, Lackey, Wang, and Webb -- and all had fine seasons. But what about Josh Beckett? This seems to be the biggest omission from Bob's column! Beckett was the only 20-game winner this year, posting a 20-7 record, with a 3.27 ERA, and 194 strikeouts. I would have honored Beckett ahead of Wang, Penny, and even Carmona, though perhaps not Lackey or Webb. As additional LHPs, Bob mentions Bedard, Santana, and Hamels, and I have no problem with that group.
For relievers, his top pick is J.J. Putz and I agree there. He then mentions Saito, Nathan, and Papelbon, and I like those picks too.
His MVPs are A-Rod and Holliday, and I agree... with Holliday barely edging Rollins in the NL. And I like his Cy Young choices of Peavy and Sabathia, though I could see Beckett winning the AL vote. Dustin Pedroia certainly had a good AL rookie campaign, so I like him getting the ROY there. The NL ROY is a tougher call, as Bob goes with Troy Tulowitzki in a tough call over Ryan Braun. Troy did play the entire season, but that is what makes Braun's numbers all the more impressive -- he has better numbers in 150-fewer at-bats -- so I give Braun the NL ROY award.
It was quite a season, and I'm looking forward to the playoffs!
Labels: baseball