I read this story in today's newspaper:
"Hawaii teacher's cure clears way for a new saint". This is yet another standard "If you pray to the name of the right dead person, then a supernatural event -- a miracle -- will occur and your wish will be granted. No lamp with a genie inside required." In this case, a woman in Hawaii was given really bad news about her cancer, and so she prayed to "Father Damien". Contrary to the dire prognosis, she has now gotten better, and she attributes this to a miracle. Doctors and Scientists rightly refer to such things as unexplained events since there is no good evidence or theory to explain what happened (I don't think the name given in the article, "complete spontaneous regression of cancer", actually explains anything from a scientific/causal standpoint).
Each time I hear a story of this kind, I think back to the "Question of Amputees". I blogged on this about a year ago:
Why Don't Miracles Ever Grow New Limbs? The idea is, why do so-called miracles so often involve really complicated medical situations, that are internal to the body, where there are complex statistics going into the prognosis/survival chances? Its almost always diseases, such as cancer, that get "cured" from the miracle. Have you ever heard of someone getting a new arm from a miracle? No. And people don't even pray for such things, at least I assume they don't. Why is that? These are meant to be rhetorical questions of course, a sort of reductio ad absurdem of claims of miracles.
By the way, the last line of the AP article read "Audrey Toguchi [the cancer survivor] still prays often to Damien, asking him to help others."
Prediction: If she prays for specific people to get healed from diseases (or for anything else really), and the desired change doesn't occur -- the press won't cover it. And I doubt she'll even mention the failures to many people. I suspect that so-called "Saints" and other supposed miracle-workers actually have an extremely low "batting average", so to speak. But how often do you see headlines like these in the news:
- Prospective Saint fails again, is now 2 for 10,497 in answering miracle requests
- Accident left victim an amputee, prayers haven't produced a new leg after 50 years
- Saint apparently indifferent to the desperate pleas of entire village
- Image of Mary on rock seems to have stopped working, as no prayers answered in past decade
Or consider this other common annoyance: athletes who pray before a game and/or thank their favorite deity for help in their victory. Again, a rhetorical question: Why don't you ever read these kinds of headlines?
- Team prays before the game, but still loses 46-7
- Player doesn't thank god after loss, noting prayer was not answered
- Player blames the Almighty after a crushing defeat
- Both teams pray before game, supernatural forces clearly favored East Jersey squad
Labels: religion